Data Analytics and Visualisation

Assessing UK City Data for GM4Women2028’s Gender Equality Scorecard

Butterfly Data assessed, pro bono, whether GM4Women2028’s gender equality Scorecard could compare cities across England, Wales and Scotland.
Download case study

Download a PDF version to read offline or share with your team.

Get in touch

Want to find out more? Get in touch with our team today to learn more about how we could help your business.

Share

Challenge

GM4Women2028 is a ten-year Greater Manchester campaign for gender equality that runs until 2028. 

Its Pankhurst-Fawcett Scorecard tracks gender equality across Greater Manchester and its ten boroughs. The campaign wanted to make inequalities visible and track whether action was making a difference, giving policymakers and campaigners the evidence they need to set priorities and hold institutions to account in Greater Manchester. 

GM4Women2028 wanted to understand whether the same approach could be used to compare major cities across England, Wales and Scotland, including Birmingham, Liverpool, Newcastle, Cardiff, Newport, Glasgow and Edinburgh. 

The challenge was to establish whether the open data needed to do this existed, was consistent across the three nations and could be compared fairly, and to turn those findings into practical guidance before the campaign ends in 2028.

Solution

Butterfly Data delivered this work pro bono. 

The team reviewed the Pankhurst-Fawcett Scorecard and relevant previous work by GM4Women2028 mapping indicators and data sources to thematic areas. Each source was assessed city by city and recorded in a structured data dictionary. 

Butterfly Data then produced a summary report setting out the findings, the data limitations by theme and source, and practical recommendations for replicating the Scorecard in other cities and continuing the work of GM4Women2028 once its ten-year campaign draws to a close in 2028.  

The report was shaped through feedback sessions with GM4Women2028 stakeholders, making sure it is clear and useful for different audiences.

Impact

GM4Women2028 now has an evidence-based account of where comparable, sex-disaggregated open data exists across UK cities and where the gaps remain. 

The report gives GM4Women2028, and those interested in undertaking a similar study in other cities and wider authorities, as well as organisations wishing to continue GM4Women2028's work beyond its 2028 end point in Greater Manchester, a practical starting point for replicating the Scorecard, setting out which sources can be refreshed routinely, which need manual compilation or devolved equivalents, and where new data collection or local partnerships would be required.

The accompanying data dictionary provides a reusable reference for future updates. 

Together, these outputs support GM4Women2028’s legacy work as its campaign draws to a close in 2028 and highlight where better sex-disaggregated data is needed to track progress on gender equality fairly.

Ready to transform your data?

Book your free discovery call and find out how our bespoke data services and solutions could help you uncover untapped potential and maximise ROI.